In brief
The agency model is a form of new car sales in which the dealership acts as a commercial agent, brokering purchase contracts in the name of the manufacturer and receiving a fee in return. The manufacturer is the customer's contracting party, bears the stock and sales risk and sets the price. If the dealership bears more than insignificant risks, this is referred to as a non-genuine agency model. Direct sales is the umbrella term: the manufacturer sells to the end customer itself.
Who sells what to whom?
Traditional dealer model
The dealer buys and resells
- Manufacturerto Dealer
sells new cars to the dealer
- Dealerto Customer
resells on its own account, the price is negotiable
Genuine agency model
The manufacturer sells directly, the dealer acts as intermediary
What is direct sales, and what is the agency model?
In direct sales, the customer concludes the purchase contract with the manufacturer rather than with the dealer. The dealership remains responsible for advice, test drive, vehicle handover and service and receives a fee for this.
The agency model is the best-known form of direct sales in automotive retail: the dealer acts as an agent in the name of the manufacturer. Alongside it there is pure direct sales without retail partners, for example through the manufacturer's own branches or exclusively online.
How does the genuine agency model work?
In the traditional dealer model, the dealer buys new cars from the manufacturer and resells them on its own account. The dealer negotiates price, discount and terms with the customer itself.
In the genuine agency model, the manufacturer is the seller. The dealer brokers the sale as a commercial agent, advises the customer, organises test drive and vehicle handover and receives a fee for this. Vehicle stock and price remain with the manufacturer.34
What is the difference between the genuine and the non-genuine agency model?
What matters is not what the contract is called but who bears the economic risk. If the dealership bears no risks or only insignificant ones, for example for stock, advertising or brand-specific investments, the manufacturer may set prices and conditions. If it bears such risks to an appreciable extent, it is treated under competition law like an independent dealer. In that case, the manufacturer may not impose a binding end price.3
In the trade press, ‘non-genuine agency model’ is also used more loosely as a name for individual manufacturers' models. If in doubt, what counts is how risk and price are governed in the specific contract.
| Dealer model | Genuine agency model | Non-genuine agency model | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer's contracting party | Dealership | Manufacturer or importer | Usually the manufacturer or importer |
| End price | Set by the dealership, the manufacturer may only recommend | Set by the manufacturer | The manufacturer may not impose it as binding |
| Stock and risk | Dealership buys and finances the vehicles | With the manufacturer, the dealership bears no risks or only insignificant ones | The dealership bears part of them, such as stock, advertising or investments |
| Dealership's earnings | Margin between purchase and selling price | Fee per vehicle, market-specific costs are borne by the manufacturer | Fee, reduced by own costs and discounts |
| Customer data | With the dealership as seller | With the manufacturer as contracting party, the dealership's access is governed by the contract | Governed by the individual contract |
Simplified presentation, not legal advice. The individual contract is decisive.
Who does what in the genuine agency model?
- Manufacturer
Sells the vehicle, sets the price and provides the shared system landscape for retail and the online channel.
- Dealer as agent
Remains the personal point of contact for the customer: advice, test drive, vehicle handover and service.
- Customer
Buys from the manufacturer, either online or at the dealership, and keeps their local contact person.
Which manufacturers have switched in Germany?
Not all manufacturers are switching to direct sales. Some sell new cars under the agency model, others have stayed with the dealer contract or returned to it. This overview only lists changeovers that the manufacturer itself has reported as completed.
- Mercedes-Benz
According to the company, Mercedes-Benz introduced the direct sales model in Germany in the second quarter of 2023.7
- BMW Group, MINI brand
The BMW Group switched sales of the MINI brand in Germany to the genuine agency model on 1 October 2024. The model had previously launched in three European countries at the beginning of 2024.12
How are fees, price and stock handled at MINI?
What are the advantages of the agency model for retailers?
- Predictable fee
There is a fixed fee per vehicle sold, even for a purely online purchase if the dealership delivers the car.1
- No discount competition for the same customer
Because the price per model is the same everywhere, dealers of the same brand no longer compete on discounts.12
- More time for advice
According to the BMW Group, partners can concentrate on advising and looking after customers.1
- Access to the entire stock
Partners can access the manufacturer's entire vehicle stock, not just the vehicles on site.1
- Less capital tied up
As a rule, retailers no longer buy and finance new cars themselves, because the manufacturer remains the seller.
What are the advantages for customers and manufacturers?
| Customers | Manufacturers | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | One nationwide price per model, online and at the dealership | Consistent pricing and offers across all channels |
| Purchase route | Free choice between dealership and online purchase, including switching between them | One purchase process that can be analysed across all channels |
| Relationship | The personal local contact remains | Direct contact with the customer instead of just dealers' sales figures |
The Customers column follows the BMW Group's statements. The Manufacturers column is our own assessment.
What are the disadvantages and risks?
- Less room for manoeuvre on price
The manufacturer sets the price. The dealership can no longer stand out from the competition through discounts.
- Greater dependence on the manufacturer
Fees, systems and processes are set by the manufacturer. If it changes the model, retailers have to follow.
- Contract and customer data with the manufacturer
The purchase contract is concluded with the manufacturer. Who may use which customer data for what purpose must be clearly defined.
- More responsibility for the manufacturer
Stock, price and contract processing lie with the manufacturer. This requires its own processes and systems.
- Less negotiation for customers
Because the price is fixed, the vehicle price can generally no longer be negotiated.
- Effort of the changeover
New contracts, systems and routines take time and tie up employees before the benefits become apparent.
How do online purchase and dealership work together?
Customers can choose freely between buying digitally and buying at the dealership, and switch between the two. The BMW Group cites a fully integrated IT system landscape as the basis for this.12
In practice, this means that a lead from the website, an appointment at the dealership and the contract with the manufacturer must come together in the same customer profile. What this looks like is shown in the article on the omnichannel sales funnel. How the introduction went at MINI is described in our case study.
What changes in the dealership's day-to-day work?
The advantages do not materialise on their own. Roles in the dealership change, the manufacturer's and retailer's systems have to work together, and employees need new routines.
- Sales
Because the price is fixed, advice, test drive and vehicle handover move to the centre.
- Systems
Orders and stock are handled through the manufacturer. What the CRM needs to be able to do for this is covered in the article CRM in the dealership.
- Management
Instead of the margin per vehicle, what counts is response time, closing rate and customer satisfaction. More on this under sales KPIs.
- Onboarding
New roles and processes have to be learned. How to succeed at this is described in the article Enabling employees.
Frequently asked questions
What is the agency model in automotive retail?
A form of new car sales in which the dealership brokers purchase contracts in the name of the manufacturer and receives a fee in return. The customer's contracting party is the manufacturer, which also sets the price.
What is the difference between direct sales and the agency model?
Direct sales is the umbrella term: the manufacturer sells to the end customer itself. The genuine agency model is one form of it, in which the retailer acts as an agent in the name of the manufacturer and receives a fee for this.
Does the dealership disappear with direct sales?
No. In the agency model, the dealership remains the personal point of contact for advice, test drive, vehicle handover and service. It simply no longer sells new cars on its own account.
What does the dealer gain from the agency model?
A predictable fee per vehicle, no discount competition with dealers of the same brand, access to the entire stock and more time for advice and service.
What are the disadvantages of the agency model for dealerships?
The dealership loses control over pricing, becomes more dependent on the manufacturer for fees, systems and processes, and the purchase contract is concluded with the manufacturer. On top of this comes the effort of the changeover.
What does the agency model mean at MINI?
Since 1 October 2024, the BMW Group has sold new MINI brand vehicles in Germany under the genuine agency model. The retail partners broker the sale, receive a fixed fee per vehicle, and a uniform price applies to each model.
Can you still negotiate the price in the agency model?
In the genuine agency model, generally not on the vehicle price, because the manufacturer sets a uniform price per model. Advice, equipment and service remain topics for discussion at the dealership.
Sources on this page
Handelsgesetzbuch, § 84 Begriff des Handelsvertreters
Retrieved on , in German
Mercedes-Benz Absatzplus im zweiten Quartal geprägt von Elektro- und Top-End-Fahrzeugen
Retrieved on , in German


